Login to ProCooling
Name: Pass:
Not Logged In.
Search:
ProCooling Technical Discussions
Overland Storage SnapOS v4 & Image File Links
kiwa 563 Day(s) ago.
/sadmin/debug.cgi
ozmatt 960 Day(s) ago.
Getting back into the water
ben333 1140 Day(s) ago.
ID This Waterblock.
jaydee 1623 Day(s) ago.
ProCooling Geek Bits
Happy 20 year on Procooling!
satanicoo 504 Day(s) ago.
Fluke 17B+ ... the multimeter I've always wanted b...
Noise 1929 Day(s) ago.
Ben's Win 98 box, redone! Build up
ben333 3584 Day(s) ago.
Project Black & Blue - Ben's new HTPC
ben333 3644 Day(s) ago.
Site News and Blogs
User Registrations kinda back open
Jag 1037 Day(s) ago.
New User Registrations are blocked
ben333 1160 Day(s) ago.
Where is Joe these days? JoeKelly.co
ben333 1451 Day(s) ago.
Stuff over the last few years, Blogs, etc...
rhkcommander 1834 Day(s) ago.
The Pro/Market
GTX 280 for US $308.11 !!!!!!
sam amaar 2307 Day(s) ago.
FS: Laptop hardware (CPUs, Memory, HDDs, Wifi, etc...
ben333 4446 Day(s) ago.
FS external watercooling units from jpiperformance...
Halo_Master 4484 Day(s) ago.
FS Snap Server 4200
abuthemagician 4609 Day(s) ago.
Waterblock Waterblock Round-Up 1
Date Posted: Jan 2 2002
Author: Joe
Posting Type: Review
Category: H2O and High End Cooling Reviews
Page: 2 of 8
Article Rank:4 from 1 Readers
Must Log In to Rank This Article
Note: This is a legacy article, imported from old code. Due to this some items on the page may not function as expected. Links, Colors, and some images may not be set correctly.
Waterblock Round-Up 1 By: Joe

The Contenders: ( Cont.)


OverClock - WaterCool AG/CU Poly (proto)

Material

Ag/Cu Eutectic Alloy - Poly Carbonate

Construction

Machined Plate with Poly Top.

Size

2"L x 1.87"W x 1.06"H

Weight

0.40 Lbs

Continuing with the OCWC tradition of thinking out of the box, is their Ag/Cu block.  This is NOT the first block to use this Eutectic alloy.  Many have tried to get this material before but due to an almost monopoly on the supply buy Wesgo Metals ( under its patented name - CuSil) most hobbyists have not been able to get it. Before now the blocks would have cost around 300$ to make out of CuSil.

BeCool had the first REAL CuSil block available about 3 or 4 months before OCWC started working on this Ag/Cu block ( can't be called CuSil since the alloy is not coming from Wesgo Metals.).

What's all the fuss about CuSil? Its a Silver and Copper mix. It's very difficult to make, and must be done in an inert atmosphere ( no Oxygen or other elements that may react with the metals).  The proportions of Copper to Silver are a trade secret to Wesgo's CuSil, but from what I am told its around 28% Copper to 72% Silver.

Why use it?  Pure silver is less than 8% better than Pure copper in heat conduction. CuSil is around 23% better than Pure Silver and 33% better than Cu!

This block is made in the same format all OCWC's Poly blocks are besides for the Ag/Cu plate at the bottom.


OverClock - WaterCool Ice Floe Poly (proto)

Material

Aluminum in a Metal Matrix Alloy - Poly Carbonate

Construction

Cast Plate with Poly Top.

Size

2.15"L x 2.15"W x 1.16"H

Weight

0.23 Lbs

This is yet another new idea from OCWC.  Instead of another Copper or Silver alloy they are trying a new Aluminum alloy. This is an alloy like not many people have seen or used. After calling around and doing a bit of research a friend confirmed to me it is an  "Aluminum alloy in a Metal or Ceramic Matrix" they use it to make Forged pistons in some high end cars, or other high heat/stress applications.

The metal is more ceramic than it is a metal.  Its brittle, doesn't bend, and cant be CNC'd well at all ( eats up bits).   Its thermal characteristics are awesome though.  Its right along with Copper for thermal conductivity.

Since these cant be milled or machined down, the plates are cast in a 2.15"x 2.15" plate.  This is nice but it is out of spec with a 2"x2" S370 size limit... For this reason, and the fact I had no retention mechanism that would let me mount flat, the block was not tested.  The reason is with 2.15" one side would always hang up on the lil cam housing that the socket has ( the lever deal).   I don't to kill the core I am working with, so the block has been side lined till a suitable retention mechanism is found.  I had the same problem with the Ag/Cu block but since it was 2" x 2" I could get a Danger Den Clip to work.


CPU FX - Reactor

Material

Aluminum // Copper

Construction

Milled Cu with Al plates bolted to it.

Size

2.5"L x 2.0"W x 2.15"H

Weight

1.8 Lbs

On the last page I mentioned that CPU FX has been around since the beginning. With that experience they have tried man different things for CPU Cooling.  Some have worked and some haven't. The Reactor is a prime example of "Haven't". This brick of metal rings in at over 2x the weight of most every other block in the review... 8x in some cases. If you care about your CPU Core weight is NOT a good thing. It has an interesting flow design of doing the cooling in a vertical fashion instead of a horizontal.  Along with the Copper center where the coolant flows, the sides have small 50mm fans.

OK... I am taking off my testing hat here, and I am going to tell you what I think.  <Personal Rant>: This this block is a new level in stupidity.  The person who designed this block and thought it was a good Idea should be shot in the head. The retention mechanism is TERRIBLE. I needed to unbolt it just to make sure it didn't shatter my core when removing it. DO NOT, I repeat DO NOT use this block in a tower style case, its so heavy it will come off contact with the core if you bump the case, and will more than likely rip the lugs off your board. I am only telling you this in order to help you avoid the issues I saw when testing this. </Personal Rant>

Ok back to the facts.  The base as a good flat surface to it. Unfortunately you cant use a Peltier with this block due to its design.  it has the same Barbs that I did not like too much on the Z3 block, and they are glued in. This block didn't leak at all.


The Testing Setup -

Back in June I showed pics of a setup I called the "Crucible" as the testing area for the blocks. Well its still there and it is what all the blocks were tested on.

Its gone through some changes:

  1. Second PSU for cool down power ( keeps the fans spinning so I can cool down the coolant faster to start another test ASAP)
  2. iOpener for temp readings. Its a stand alone temp recording point, works VERY well. its my 3rd iOpener :)
  3. Inline Thermal probes to record coolant temp ( on my 4th pair of them after a few bad designs).

Here are some close up pics and description on what they do in this setup.

The Pump is the good Ole HydroThruster 500GPH pump I used on the Radiator Roundup tests.

This is an awesome pump, and runs reliably 100% of the time.  Never a leak, never a stray noise.  Yes you can find higher GPH pumps, but few that are as nice as this baby.

The radiator is the winner of the Radiator Roundup done a few months ago. The OCWC - Big Momma.

It has 2 120mm H1A Panaflo's on it one pushing and one pulling. The front and back fans have 1 DD5 thermal probe for air temp.  The Intake fan also has one thermocouple from the ExTech thermometer to meter the intake air and compare that with the core temp. just to keep dust a non issue the radiator was blown out every few blocks.

The front and back of the radiator was kept free from anything that may limit the breathing ability of the fans.

From the show that has taught me all I need to know about life : The Red Green Show - "Duct Tape - The Handy Mans Secret Weapon".  Anything can be made with Duct tape, and I mean anything. Like in this pic, you see how a DD5, a Compu Nurse, a Pump flow control box, and a crushed Vantec HSF box can make a killer control panel with enough Duct tape :)

So it isn't pretty, who cares, it works, and it didn't catch fire, not even once!

The CompuNurse was like a neutral 3rd party, it let me know if the ambient temp was moving at all, that way I could compensate before the radiator would feel the effects. the Pump control is how you adjusted the flow and speed of the pump.  The DD5 was reporting these temps : Air in, Air out, Coolant in and Coolant out.

The Flow meter used in these tests was the Swiss Flow digital meter.  Using it with MBM on the test machine it was easy to read the flow rate.

The Test board - A Abit KT7A. Still working after all the abuse its been though. ( been abused for 10 months now like this)

The CPU - Athlon Thunder Bird 1.4Ghz @ 1.6Ghz @1.85Vcore.  This CPU has been used with roughly 30 water blocks, 20 HSF's, and about 50+ remounting's of them. The core is flawless, I could clean it off and sell it as new.  There is not as much as a slight nick or chip out of it. So... For those girls out there who say you need a Shim, No you don't, you just need a clue on how to mount a HSF/WB. I have mounted HSF's that people say cant be mounted with out breaking a core. Heck I even mounted that OCH Reactor!.    Shims.. Ditch the training wheels, if you rely on them too much some day you wont know how to ride without them.

This is one of the inline coolant probes.  I found this neat Y fitting at a local Lab Surplus place I hang at. Its 2 3/8" fittings and 1 1/4" fitting.  Perfect for this. I had a bunch of issues with them cracking early on. That was cause I over tightened the lil knob down. so now its just on a lil with silicone sealer, and Goop. Lasted for 4 months like this without as much as a slight leak.

The Thermistor is a standard DD5 Bulb type.  Its been coated in silicone ( all except for the top of the bulb) to keep all water out. and the hole is then plugged with a red piece of rubber and epoxy.

The Good Ole ExTech thermometer! I love this lil toy :)

Its responsible for 75% of all the temp data you will see in the tests. It gathers temp's every 6 seconds ( so its sync'd with the MBM's temp logging time frame for the mobo temp probe).

The temps are recorded from under the CPU core and the intake air to the radiator.

All the blocks were held down with one of the retention mechanisms off to the left.


The Testing Methodology is Next

Random Forum Pic
Random Forum Pic
From Thread:
My new DD pump arrived!
ProCooling Poll:
So why the hell not?
I agree! 67%
What? 17%
Hell NO! 0%
Worst Poll Ever. 17%
Total Votes:18
Please Login to Vote!



(C) ProCooling.com 2005 - All this glorious web geekness was brought to you by Joe's amateur web coding skills.
If we in some way offend you, insult you or your people, screw your mom, beat up your dad, or poop on your porch... we're sorry... we were probably really drunk...
Oh and dont steal our content bitches! Don't give us a reason to pee in your open car window this summer...